Diverse interpretations
600 C.E.–1450
- Diverse interpretations
- What are the issues involved in using cultural areas rather than states as units of analysis?
- Political boundaries
- Yes, they might have centralized government, but…different people forced to live together
- More centralized you get, the more organized you are, but…cultures oftentimes keep people united more than government
- Political boundaries oftentimes based on convenient geographic factors, but don’t take cultural differences into account
- Cultural Boundaries
- During post-classical era – easier to write about regions in terms of cultural areas
- Muslim World
- Jewish Community
- Religion a good way to divide
- Christian sphere, Islamic sphere, Hindu sphere, Buddhist sphere
- but…some overlap (Confucianism and Buddhism)
- and…some are quite different (Eastern Europe vs. Western Europe)
- Consider grouping the world into cultures that interacted vs. cultures that didn’t
- During post-classical era – easier to write about regions in terms of cultural areas
- Political boundaries
- What are the sources of change: nomadic migrations versus urban growth?
- Nomadic Migrations
- Urban Growth
- As populations grew, people needed to spread out
- Made more crowded conditions on manor/in cities
- Creation of guilds – labor groups that maintain monopoly
- Restricted membership, established prices/quality standards
- Cities become larger, more opportunities
- Pulled more from the countryside
- Cities also grew because they were established as centers of civilization
- Constantinople – built to be city center
- Capitals created to create aura of rising empire
- Islamic Empire moves to Baghdad
- Japan moves to Heian
- Mongols built Smarkand
- Location of universities
- Leads to more cultural diffusion
- People who would have never interacted, now interact
- Pilgrimages – constantly on move
- Rome/Constantinople attracted to huge cathedrals
- Islamic trip to Mecca most significant
- From vast reaches of Islamic empire to Mecca
- Think of Mansa Musa
- Growth of cities due to increased trade
- Towns located near rivers/waterways
- Became marketplaces where goods could be sold
- But…overcrowded, polluted, people lived in abject poverty
- Benefit – immunity from feudal obligations
- Year and a day rule
- Urbanization in high Middle Ages
- service providers/craftspeople set up businesses in towns – stimulates growth
- barbers, blacksmiths, coopers (barrels), jewelers, tanners, innkeepers, wine/beer merchants
- Cities had to plan growth, regulate business, collect taxes
- Wealthy towns in Italy invested in new buildings/statuary for beautification
- service providers/craftspeople set up businesses in towns – stimulates growth
- As populations grew, people needed to spread out
- Was there a world economic network in this period?
- By 1200 CE, the world was very interconnected
- Europe trading with Islamic world and Russia
- Islamic world trading with Africa, India, China
- India trading with China, East Africa
- China trading with Japan/S. East Europe
- So….goods could go from England to Persia to India to Japan or
- Muscovy to Mali
- not controlled by one entity/one trading organization
- Web of interconnected parts
- Lots of managers at each site
- But…is it direct/indirect trade
- Many intermediaries
- Europe dependent on Silk Road/nomadic leaders
- Can be shut down easily due to ruling parties
- The Americas? Australia? Southern Africa? If 3 of 7 continents not involved…?
- By 1200 CE, the world was very interconnected
- Were there common patterns in the new opportunities available to and constraints placed on elite women in this period?
- Overview – could play key political, social, economic roles, but conduct strictly regulated
- Europe
- Negatives
- Chivalry – idea that women are delicate, beautiful, need to be protected
- Traditional roles of homemaker/childcare provider
- Code of chivalry reinforced women as weak/subordinate
- Positives
- Could exert great deal of political and cultural influence
- Aristocratic heir to rich property/kingdom > extremely important
- Managed estates and accounts in men’s absence
- Mothers of young kings whose father’s died served as regents/advisors
- Some non Germanic kingdoms could see women take throne
- Eleanor of Aquitaine – richest heiress of France
- Married to Louis VII of France
- Henry II of medieval England
- Convents offered women opportunities
- Service in communities
- Women in towns a bit more freedom
- Allowed to participate in trade/craft guilds
- Could exert great deal of political and cultural influence
- Negatives
- China
- Negatives
- Subject to restrictions
- Women needed to produce dowry
- Marriages made to benefit groom
- Foot-binding – crippling to look tiny/dainty
- Positives
- Inheritance and property rights
- Retained control of dowry after divorce/husband’s death
- Negatives
- Europe
- What are the issues involved in using cultural areas rather than states as units of analysis?
Subject:
US History [1]
Subject X2:
US History [1]