Sources of Political Innovations
1914 to Present
- Sources of Political Innovations
- Democratization
- Expansion of popular representation
- Women allowed to vote in Western nations then worldwide
- Expansion of popular representation
- Interwar years
- Democracies weak
- Totalitarian dictatorships most dynamic
- Control as many aspects of citizen’s lives as possible
- Waning of democracy in interwar Europe
- After WWI, 23 govts democratic, by 1939 – only 12
- Fell victim to political extremism
- Stress of Great Depression – mass unemployment/inflation
- Replaced with right wing dictatorships
- Ethnic discrimination/blame
- Class tensions
- France and Britain struggling
- Financially strapped due to WWI
- Need loans from US and reparations from Germany to survive
- Leads to unemployment, strikes, and deficits
- No one political party can offer leadership
- France – frequent elections – power goes from left to right
- Strongest and most dynamic governments were dictatorships
- Fascism – destroy will of the individual for the sake of “the people”
- Italy – revolution came from the right
- Plagued by depression, political turmoil, threat of communism
- Constant strikes, turnover in government
- Middle and upper class afraid of left-wing revolution
- Need a strong leader
- Enter anti-communist, Fascist Benito Mussolini
- Fascism – revolution from the right, right-wing radicalism
- Doesn’t prevent change, brings about change
- Anticommunist, anticapitalist, antidemocratic
- Hypernationalism
- State-sponsored racial/ethnic bigotry
- Democracy weak and ineffective
- Blackshirts – paid paramilitary
- Fight socialist/communist organizations
- Mussolini convinced King Victor Emmannuel to appoint
- Had Blackshirts march to Rome – looks intimidating
- King timid man – afraid to call in military
- Faced financial problems
- Maybe financial plans would work
- Fascism – revolution from the right, right-wing radicalism
- New form of government – totalitarianism
- Uses modern technology, bureaucracy to control everyone
- Mussolini mild compared to Hitler/Stalin
- Imposed censorship, controlled culture
- Put dissidents in prison
- Propaganda to create cult of personality – larger than life
- Attempts to modernize Italy
- Built modern highways
- Sponsored literacy
- Fought Mafia
- Brought medicine/technology to backwards parts
- Made inefficient trains run on time
- Syndicalism – state-sponsored capitalism w/ no unions
- Corporate leaders must cooperate with government
- Many actually thought he was successful
- Depression made it hard to be dictatorial and successful
- Also…started adopting some of Hitler’s methods
- Master becomes the student
- Also…started adopting some of Hitler’s methods
- Unite people to nationalistic cause – invades North Africa
- Plagued by depression, political turmoil, threat of communism
- Germany
- Causes
- Governed by democratic regime – Weimar Republic
- Hyperinflation – wiped out value of German mark
- Burden of war payments
- Resentment of the Treaty of Versailles
- Crushed national pride
- Rise of extremist national parties
- Communist Party – left
- The Nazi Party
- anticommunist, antidemocratic
- Imitated Italian fascism
- Obsessed with racial purity
- Hated all minorities, especially subhuman Jews
- Tried and failed to take over in 1923 – Beerhall Putcsh
- Hitler writed Mein Kampf in jail
- Effect of the Depression
- 6 million – 40% unemployed
- Political boost to extremist parties
- Weimar Republic can’t govern conservatively
- Nazi Party becomes largest party in 1932
- Convinces Hindenberg to appoint him chancellor
- Hitler
- Uses burning of Reichstag building to justify war powers
- Enabling Act – March 1933
- Suspended Weimar Constitution for 4 years
- Enabling Act – March 1933
- Actions as dictator
- Outlaws all political parties
- Took control of the press
- Banned labor unions
- System of state capitalism
- Built concentration camps for opponents/dissidents
- Established secret police – Gestapo
- Ended unemployment
- Public works projects/highways
- Arms production
- Act against Jews – “undesirables”
- Forced out of professions
- law, civil service,university
- Businesses boycotted
- Nuremberg Laws – 1935
- Stripped of citizenship
- Forbade marriage/sex – Jews/non
- Forced out of professions
- Uses burning of Reichstag building to justify war powers
- Causes
- Totalitarianism on the Right and the Left
- Russian Marxist revolution and communism scared the bejeepers
- Groups of reactionary men organized to fight its spread
- Stalinism – Soviet communism
- Centralized control of the economy
- World leadership of international communist movement
- Forced collectivization of all farming
- promotion of atheism and control of organized religion
- Features of totalitarianism
- single leader with unquestioned authority
- single party in charge of all of government
- creation of police state to terrorize/control
- aggressive elimination of all opposition groups
- Russian Marxist revolution and communism scared the bejeepers
- Italy – revolution came from the right
- Primary form of organization becomes democratic state + capitalism
- Comparing Fascism and Totalitarianism
- Fascism vs. communism
- Fascists don’t want to eliminate private property, class distinctions
- Pushed for another identity – extreme nationalism based on racial identity
- Fascism is subset of totalitarianism
- Totalitarian dictator rules absolutely
- Fascists type of totalitarian rule
- Right wing
- Rely on traditional institutions/social distinctions to enforce rule
- Extreme nationalism based on racism
- Communism
- Extreme left-wing
- Seek to destroy traditional institutions and class distinctions
- But they want to retain power for themselves
- Not fascist, but just as militaristic and controlling
- Both use same tactics - totalitarianism
- Fascism vs. communism
- Number of regimes try communism
- Communist economy
- Dictatorial political system
- Communism in the Soviet Union
- Initially moderate parliament Provisional Government took over
- Tried to set up democratic state – looked like French Revolution
- Alexander Kerensky – provisional government
- Ineffective – shared power with local soviets
- Soviets represented views of workers, peasants, soldie
- Also…wanted to continue war against Germany
- Peasants want to end the suffering of the war
- Too idealistic, didn’t gauge Russian people
- Did affirm natural rights – religious toleration, equality of cit
- Ineffective – shared power with local soviets
- But…Bolshevik Party promised land reform, economic stability, and peace
- Fought war of Bolsheviks (Communists) Reds vs. Whites (anti-com)
- Vladimir Lenin – April Theses – peace, land, power to soviets
- Lenin pulls out of WWI – Treaty of Brest-Litovsk
- Western Russia to Germany for cease fire
- Counterrevolutionary revolts across Russia
- Bolsheviks must fight nonstop skirmishes for 3 years
- Trotsky’s Red Army vs. the Whites
- Results of civil war
- West supported counterrevolutionaries = mistrust
- Bolsheviks now had a very powerful Red Army
- Bolsheviks must fight nonstop skirmishes for 3 years
- Lenin tries to modernize Soviet Union in Marxist fashion
- Problem…USSR not a capitalist gov’t – can’t seize factories
- Tries to nationalize assets/industries
- Initial programs actually result in decline
- Institutes New Economic Policy (NEP)
- Permitted some private ownership
- Led to increase in productivity
- Permitted some private ownership
- Organized into a series of socialist republics under central gov’t
- 1923 renamed Union of Soviet Socialist Republics
- Problem…USSR not a capitalist gov’t – can’t seize factories
- Stalin takes over power – beats out Trotsky
- Hyper modernizes through Five-Year Plans
- Collectivization of agriculture – all peasants > state-run farm
- Huge collective farms worked by common farmers
- Farmers share the proceeds
- Millions of kulaks – peasants with more land
- Executed or deported
- Government controls countryside
- Money used to finance industrialization
- Five Year Plans successful
- Focus on heavy industry
- Collectivization of agriculture – all peasants > state-run farm
- Negatives of collectivization
- famine – lack of worker initiative
- Became Great Purges – Stalin becomes paranoid
- Expulsion/execution of rivals
- Perceived dissidents sent to work camps – gulags
- Uses propaganda to glorify himself, mind-control nation
- Hyper modernizes through Five-Year Plans
- Does the end justify the means?
- Initially moderate parliament Provisional Government took over
- Communism in China
- Nationalists vs. Communists
- Early 1920s – Nationalist-Communist alliance drives out warlords
- Nationalists – Chiang Kai-shek
- Communists – Mao Tse-tung
- While Mao leads Long March north, Chiang consolidates power
- Founds Nanjing Republic
- Combination of Westernization and authoritarianism
- Sun’s Three People’s Principles
- Attempted constitutional gov’t, industrial economy
- Impossible to be successful with
- Backwardness
- Threat of Japanese imperialism
- Warlord anarchy
- Mao makes Communism attractive to peasants
- Founds Nanjing Republic
- Early 1920s – Nationalist-Communist alliance drives out warlords
- Nationalists vs. Communists
- Third World nations experiment w/ variety of governments
- Dictatorship in Latin America
- Outside Influences on Latin America
- Prior to WWI, politically independent, but economically dependent
- US/Western investors controlled enterprises
- Economies based on export of 1 or 2 products – monoculture
- Chile – fertilizer, copper
- Mexico, Bolivia, Argentina, Peru – oil
- Argentina – beef
- Caribbean/Brazil – sugar
- Brazil – 75% of world’s coffee
- Foreigners allowed influence on local politics
- In exchange for capital and industrial knowledge
- Mass of population did work, but didn’t benefit
- Prior to WWI, politically independent, but economically dependent
- The United States in Latin America
- France/Britain can’t invest in L. America, US can
- US views L. America as they’re sphere of influence
- To what extent did they control
- Gained territory – Puerto Rico, Virgin Islands
- Military presence – Panama
- Sponsored dictators for order – Venezuela, Cuba
- Good Neighbor Policy – Roosevelt – reduce US role
- Even pulled troops from Haiti – no troops in L. Amer
- Great Depression effects
- US inability to purchase exports killed L. America
- Remember they’re monoculture – dependent on exports
- Economic problems had negative effect on politics
- Long standing tradition of authoritarian rule
- Few if any genuine democracies in 1920s/1930s
- Mexico, Brazil, Argentina – all turn dictator
- US inability to purchase exports killed L. America
- Mexico
- Been in chaos since Benito Juarez died in 1872
- Rebels like Ponsho Villa and Emiliana Zapata fight dictator
- US helped but down rebels – tired of their raids
- Institutional Revolutionary Party – name not accurate
- Granted suffrage and right to strike
- But…actually ruled by an oligarchy that chose president
- Upper class prospers, country modernizes
- But…middle class small…lower class huge
- Lazaro Cardenas – president 1934
- Redistributes 40 million acres – land reform
- Nationalized oil industry – took from US
- Roosevelt did nothing – he’s a Good Neighbor
- Mexico pays US then forms – PEMEX
- Mexico emerges from revolution with one party system
- PRI – Partido Revolucionario Institucional
- Dominated politics for 70 years
- PRI – Partido Revolucionario Institucional
- Brazil
- Before 1930, nation run by wealthy coffee growers
- Depression killed coffee industry
- 1930 Getulio Vargas takes over – mimics Fascist Italy/Germany
- Censored press
- Tortured political opponents
- Modernized Brazilian economy
- Diversified and freed from coffee reliance
- Brazil becomes L. America’s most industrialized nat
- Army forces out in 1945
- Before 1930, nation run by wealthy coffee growers
- Argentina
- 1916 – Radical Party – Hipolito Irigoyen – labor party
- Reforms benefit peasants
- Labor unions become more active
- Landowners, upper class + military overthrow him in 1930
- Military tries to return to export-based economy
- Labor unrest increases – descamisados – “shirtless ones”
- After WWII – Evan and Juan Peron take over – appeal to lower
- Raised the salaries of the working class
- Government controlled press, denied civil liberties
- Ruled by military dictators after Peron
- 1916 – Radical Party – Hipolito Irigoyen – labor party
- Outside Influences on Latin America
- Dictatorship in Latin America
- Militarism in Japan
- Early 1920s Japan looks like its heading toward parliamentary capitalism
- Power of Diet increases
- Political parties more active/relevant
- Universal male suffrage
- Bill of rights
- Less censoring of media
- Economy continued to industrialize/modernize
- But…traditional forces still exist
- Upper classes maintains system of oligarchy
- Nationalism runs high
- Industrialization concentrated in small group of zaibatsu
- Four largest (Mitsubishi) controlled a ton
- 21% banking, 35% shipbuilding, 21% mining
- Wealth doesn’t benefit masses – controlled by elite few
- Direct link to government – government has vested interest
- Looks a bit like Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany
- Four largest (Mitsubishi) controlled a ton
- Militarism and Invasion of Asia
- Major cause – Great Depression
- Exports drop 50%
- Nationalism skyrocketed, anti-Westernism grew
- Rise of Nationalism
- Kita Ikki – celebrity – right wing nationalist
- “Asia for Asians” – kick out Europeans
- Kita Ikki – celebrity – right wing nationalist
- Takes over Manchuria – Manchukuo
- Install Henry Pu-yi – remember him – last emperor of China
- Japan withdraws from League of Nations
- Prime Minister assassinated
- Emperor Hirohito controlled by military
- War starts in 1937 – New Order – Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere
- Attacked in full force
- Committed dreadful atrocities
- “Rape of Nanjing” – 200,000 > 300,000 women/children
- Then push to Southeast Asia – push out French and British
- Major cause – Great Depression
- Early 1920s Japan looks like its heading toward parliamentary capitalism
- Rebuilding Europe after WWII
- Soviet Bloc – COMECON - Council for Mutual Economic Assistance
- Economies nationalized/centrally planned
- Collectivization under state control
- Massive industrialization
- “socialist division of labor” – every nation focuses in a few areas
- Soviet welfare systems
- education, medical care, pensions
- Poor quality consuper goods
- Focus on heavy industry/weapons
- Maintained through political repression
- Western Europe – Marshall Plan – European Recovery Plan
- A “miracle” – helped prevent the spread of communism
- W. Germany rose from ruins – European economic powerhouse
- Technical innovation – move to postindustrial world
- Put into place social welfare systems
- Created “third way” – blend of capitalism and social-welfare
- But…problems
- Germany refuses initially to acknowledge Holocaust
- French corrupt leaders, protests leads to 1968 revolution
- Mild authoritarian regimes continue Spain, Portugal, Greece
- Soviet Bloc – COMECON - Council for Mutual Economic Assistance
- Israel creates unique form of democracy
- Militaristic state run democratically that is huge human rights violator
- Must be violent toward poorly armed and minors to ensure security
- Authoritarianism and Dictatorship
- Latin America
- Middle East
- Monarchies – Morocco, Jordan, Saudi Arabia
- Dictatorships – Syria, Lybia, Iraq
- Egypt/Turkey – need to combat Islamic extremism
- Heaviness of governmental control
- Elections not completely open
- Civil rights constrained
- Media not entirely free
- Israel democracy compromised by harshness in putting down Palestinians
- Heaviness of governmental control
- Southeast Asia after World War II
- Overview
- British gave up colonies relatively easily
- Malaysia, Singapore, Burma, Hong Kong
- French/Dutch a little hesitant
- Militarism/authoritarianism dominant method of rule
- Cambodia
- Khmer Rouge – took power tried reverse industrialization
- Killed 2 million people, devastated economy, politics
- Philippines
- Ferdinand Marcos
- US backed
- Violated civil rights, extraordinarily corrupt
- Ferdinand Marcos
- South Korea ruled similarly to Philippines
- Myanmar and Thailand came under military rule
- Singapore
- Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew
- Pushes for conformity and tradition
- Devalues freedom and civil liberties
- Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew
- Cambodia
- British gave up colonies relatively easily
- Indonesia
- After WWII, Netherlands controlled Dutch East Indies – Indonesia
- Charismatic leader of Indonesian Nationalist Party
- Led war of liberation in 1945
- Afraid of Communist takeover, US convinced Dutch to give up
- New nation has diversity issues
- One of largest in world – linguistically, ethnically, religiously diff
- Tried governing democratically, but…too many groups
- Turned to authoritarian
- 1950s dissolved constitution for “Guided Democracy”
- Started to align himself with Communists
- 1965 army + Conservative Muslims overthrew Sukarno
- 500,000 killed – mostly Communists
- Sukarno eventually forced out of office
- 1967-1998 – military strongman General Suharto ruled
- Dictator with frequent human-rights abuses
- Focuses
- Economic growth
- Anticommunism
- Alliance with the United States
- Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia
- France tried to hold on for a decade after WWII
- Ho Chi Minh thinks he can gain independence
- Saw how US supported Philippines
- Proved himself against Japanese in WWII
- Vietnamese nationalism from under Marxist-taught Ho
- 1945 – Ho Chi Minh writes Declaration of Independence
- But…US supports France
- Important to make them happy – Germany more important
- Ho Chi Minh fights French w/ US backing
- Humiliated at Dien Bien Phu
- France wants out – signs treaty at Geneva Conference – 1954
- Nations of Laos, Cambodia, Vietnam created
- Vietnam divided north/south – elections in a 2 years
- Nations of Laos, Cambodia, Vietnam created
- Ho Chi Minh thinks he’s getting an election – 2 years comes and passes
- South Vietnamese leader Ngo Dinh Diem refuses elections
- He’d lose – he’s Catholic, US puppet (kindof)
- Ho Chi Minh had enough – moves South
- Viet Minh in the North
- Viet Cong communist resistance in the South
- South Vietnamese leader Ngo Dinh Diem refuses elections
- US supports South for years, but its useless
- Guerilla warfare too successful vs. conventional
- Doesn’t have support of the masses
- Peasants hate South Vietnamese government
- US arranges for Ngo Dinh Diem’s overthrow
- US realizes they have no chance after Tet Offensive – 1968
- Gradually start pulling out
- 1975 Communist backed Ho Chi Minh captures South and unifies country
- Laos and Cambodia also fall to communists
- Overview
- Democratization
Subject:
US History [1]
Subject X2:
US History [1]