Peer graded by ____________ Grade = *Note- Students may receive grades of 3.5, 2.5, or 1.5 A grade of 3.5 is given when the student has done everything on the rubric but the sentences are not as clear as they should be and the paper is lacking observations or arguments. 4 3 2 1 Exceeds Expectations High quality Basic In Progress Summary is made of 7 clear sentences States main idea Discusses key issues and details Critique is made of 7 thoughtful sentences Perceptive observations/argument Critique backed by facts and examples Bibliography/Citation includes the article title, name of author, date of publication Summary is made of 5 clear sentences Major details addressed Critique is made of 5 sentences Clear evidence of opinions